February 9, 2016

Being Dragged Kicking and Screaming

“Mr. V., we need a break.  Can we have the day off?” This question came from an alto sitting in the back of the room and was met with a few sympathetic murmurs from other ladies in her section. To give context, often these types of questions are asked just after school days have been shortened due to inclement weather, I have been at a choral festival, we have upcoming shorten weeks and our first choir festival/competition is in just a few weeks. 

To be fair, all teachers are accustomed to similar scenarios.  As we are all aware, our profession frequently requires that we be flexible.  It is a bit delusional to create long-term plans under the assumptions of uninterrupted class time and optimal student attendance.  Nevertheless, the minutes we spend with our students are priceless, and we are unwilling to surrender any more of them than necessary.

Even so, many of our students are indifferent to the urgency of our circumstances.  Ultimately, no matter how competently a teacher presents curriculum, the learner outcome will rarely meet or exceed expectations if the student is not invested.  Therefore, if I must, I can drag you kicking and screaming to competence, but you must have the desire to achieve excellence. 


Here are five factors to consider that have an effect on student motivation:


1
As difficult as this can be to remember, the classes we teach are not the only classes in the school.


2
We all enjoy the subject we have chosen to teach.  The majority of my students are typically more aware of the artistic ideals associated with Adele or Ed Sheeran than those of the Mormon Tabernacle Choir.  For this reason, it is crucial to implement strategies that engage students in various dialogues and scenarios that increase student understanding.  By and large, students are more willing to seek an aesthetic they have connected with ownership. 


3
If students are only aware of long-term goals, they may not be motivated to meet those goals, especially if they believe them to be impossible.  Perhaps a more effective solution would be to set short-term goals.  These types of goals set the stage for high student morale.


4
One of the greatest obstacles we face is the “Old-Time Religion Syndrome.” To borrow a line from the spiritual, “It was good for my grandmother; it’s good for me.” No matter the assessment type, students assume the responsibility to recall the lessons and objectives they have learned in class.  Parents and grandparents that observe their student’s classroom performance often praise the child, the classroom, the administrators, and the school district, but this praise shouldn’t be the sole standard to which we aspire.  


5
When we encounter students who do not desire excellence for themselves and are not interested in being embarrassed by poor performance, we should take a step back and realize that this student can still achieve excellence.  It is imperative that no attempt be made to shame a child into mastery of standards; this will never work.  Instead increase positivity, decrease negativity, and observe the improvement in the classroom.


How often do we forget that just as our stress can be transferred to our students, so, too, can our motivation?  Do you enjoy teaching your subject(s) of expertise? I hope so.  Our students should be able to know from observing us that we enjoy working with them and that we’re giving them the best we have to offer.  External factors can drag us kicking and screaming to competence, but a true educator strives for excellence.